香港新浪網 MySinaBlog
« 上一篇 | 下一篇 »
Chris | 11-02-09, 6:13 AM | 時事觸角 | (1258 Reads)

澳洲惡名昭彰的「死亡醫生」Jayant Patel 的審訊,這個星期開始了。

原本服務於昆士蘭Bundaberg市醫院為外科主任醫生的印度裔美國人Jayant Patel,2005年涉嫌長其草率決定進行多項手術,但是技術不濟和屢有失誤,導至可能多至幾十人死亡。一個護士長多番向上級舉報,卻遭受污衊和壓制,她不畏強權,向外間揭發。Patel 匆忙逃回美國,消息傳出,輿論嘩然,死者親屬大慟,要求追究Patel和院方管理層的責任。經過幾年的冗長偵查和法律程序,卒之在2008年中,得到美國警方的協助把他拘捕,引渡回澳洲受審。

 

他起碼要面對十多項誤殺指控,法庭也會傳召超過100名證人。

澳洲行使英國式的普通法,任何人在法庭定罪之前,均是假設無罪(Presumed Innocent Until the Contrary Is Proved) 。他解返澳洲到上庭的幾個月時間,居然給他申請到保釋在外候審,不用關在監獄

由於案件特殊,受害人眾多,澳洲政府恐怕會有人忍不住要「替天行道」私自執法,在審訊之前先把他幹掉,於是要為他做足保護措施 。

這是應該的,但我想不到會是這樣的優待:

政府在一個秘密的地方給他住所,每星期租金要500多元澳幣,簡直是豪宅級數。

另外,因為他不能露面和工作,政府每個星期發給他 700多元澳幣的生活費,這個數目優厚,比一般澳洲國民能夠拿到的養老金,足足多了一倍以上!

在文明的國家犯了法,真是「坐監也風流」。

BBC 新聞   Australia's "Doctor Death" (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4080164.stm)

(文章允許轉貼,請具作者名字:梁煥松)
 


[1]

not fair~

linerak
[引用] | 作者 linerak | 11-02-09 6:55 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[2]

一個月有二千八百元澳幣,若乘以五,就有一萬四千港元。

醫療事故,處處都有。若要做不必要的手術,要認真考慮。


[引用] | 作者 Raymond | 11-02-09 7:47 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[3] Re: Raymond
Raymond :
一個月有二千八百元澳幣,若乘以五,就有一萬四千港元。
醫療事故,處處都有。若要做不必要的手術,要認真考慮。
這個事件,上下都失職。他在美國因多番犯錯遭停牌,申請澳洲工作輕易過關,院方沒詳細審查其資歷。
新聞記者用Google 一搜便找到了。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 7:57 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[4] Re: 來恩

其實可以嘗試說因為他試過逃走,所以申請拘留﹖


[引用] | 作者 方潤 | 11-02-09 9:18 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[5]

在英國普通法下,要 "告入" 醫生是不是很難? 法律通常是 on medical doctors' side.
另,不知市價,月租500澳元就是豪宅?


[引用] | 作者 Darling | 11-02-09 10:58 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[6]

真係超唔公平...佢又唔係咩特別身份..點解會有咁多好嘅待遇...


[引用] | 作者 Vikki | 11-02-09 11:05 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[7] Re: 方潤
方潤 :
其實可以嘗試說因為他試過逃走,所以申請拘留﹖
法庭下令不准保釋還押候審就好了,政府省回不少錢。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 12:57 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[8] Re: Darling
Darling :
在英國普通法下,要 "告入" 醫生是不是很難? 法律通常是 on medical doctors' side.
另,不知市價,月租500澳元就是豪宅?
這個倒沒研究了。
是週租 $500!

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 12:59 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[9] Re: Vikki
Vikki :
真係超唔公平...佢又唔係咩特別身份..點解會有咁多好嘅待遇...
如果上訴又上訴,再審一年半載,納稅人真是不見很多錢。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 1:00 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[10]

為甚麼一個受過良好教育的人可以如此卑劣??


[引用] | 作者 megc | 11-02-09 1:42 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[11] Re: megc
megc :
為甚麼一個受過良好教育的人可以如此卑劣??
這個Patel出身富裕家庭,家族之中出了14個醫生----他老婆也是醫生。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 1:48 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[12]

5xx + 7xx ~ 1300 Per Week! That's about 90k Per Annum before tax. And he doesn't have to work! Shame!


[引用] | 作者 Guybrush Threepwood | 11-02-09 1:52 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[13] Re: Guybrush Threepwood
Guybrush Threepwood :
5xx + 7xx ~ 1300 Per Week! That's about 90k Per Annum before tax. And he doesn't have to work! Shame!
應該入冊咬皇家飯的。
現在才提堂於裁判署,有待 Commital到地院,又不知道會不會打到高院,有排佢嘆!

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 2:07 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[14] Re: Chris
Chris :
megc :為甚麼一個受過良好教育的人可以如此卑劣??這個Patel出身富裕家庭,家族之中出了14個醫生----他老婆也是醫生。

這個是一老掉牙的問題...你可說 "Professionals" 是受過 "良好教育" , 但實情可能只是 "嚴格訓練(Training for exams)" , 個人品格跟一般人期望時有出入。 當然,我相信主角僅屬少數害群之馬吧。

Chris兄,"一般" apartment or house 的週租又是多少?


[引用] | 作者 Darling | 11-02-09 2:15 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[15] Re: Vikki
Vikki :
真係超唔公平...佢又唔係咩特別身份..點解會有咁多好嘅待遇...

無辦法,呢d係法治嘅代價。

在hk,曾有警官因涉嫌貪污受查,case 一拖拖了3-4年,警官(未定罪,只是疑犯)被停職,但一切薪酬福利照支,閒時讀了個law degree (公務員津貼?),更考了個大律師牌。

人世事可以十分荒謬。


[引用] | 作者 Darling | 11-02-09 2:31 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[16] Re: Darling
Darling :
Chris :
megc :為甚麼一個受過良好教育的人可以如此卑劣??這個Patel出身富裕家庭,家族之中出了14個醫生----他老婆也是醫生。

這個是一老掉牙的問題...你可說 "Professionals" 是受過 "良好教育" , 但實情可能只是 "嚴格訓練(Training for exams)" , 個人品格跟一般人期望時有出入。 當然,我相信主角僅屬少數害群之馬吧。
Chris兄,"...

Apartment多數在市中心,500元一星期夠有餘。假如在住宅區,花園獨立屋也不用400。
以上是他接受審訊的Brisbane市的價錢。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 2:56 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[17] Re: Darling
Darling :
Vikki :
真係超唔公平...佢又唔係咩特別身份..點解會有咁多好嘅待遇...
無辦法,呢d係法治嘅代價。
在hk,曾有警官因涉嫌貪污受查,case 一拖拖了3-4年,警官(未定罪,只是疑犯)被停職,但一切薪酬福利照支,閒時讀了個law degree (公務員津貼?),更考了個大律師牌。
人世事可以十分荒謬。

可以算是世紀奇談。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 2:57 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[18]

對啊, 特別是那些商業罪案, 判刑很輕, 甚至不會充公財產, 很多罪犯, 就乖乖地去坐幾年牢, 然後就可以享受人生了.


[引用] | 作者 嚴明 | 11-02-09 4:28 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[19]

It's funny that the Australian government let someone who lost his license in the States to work as a physician in Australia, but they had turned down the application for immigration of a German doctor twice, because he has a son with Down Syndrome.

tin tin
[引用] | 作者 tin tin | 11-02-09 8:45 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[20] Re: 嚴明
嚴明 :
對啊, 特別是那些商業罪案, 判刑很輕, 甚至不會充公財產, 很多罪犯, 就乖乖地去坐幾年牢, 然後就可以享受人生了.
澳洲,一般法官是性善信徒,判刑很輕。
有些是判了之島緩刑,即是不用入獄。
有些是判 N 年,但是判刑時已講明坐三分一或一半便可申請假釋!

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 9:29 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[21] Re: tin tin
tin tin :
It's funny that the Australian government let someone who lost his license in the States to work as a physician in Australia, but they had turned down the application for immigration of a German docto...
有些公務人員做事得過且過,有人做事又太過一板一眼完全不懂轉彎。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 11-02-09 9:31 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[22]

又一學歷高不表示道德高的實理

毫無人性
[引用] | 作者 毫無人性 | 11-02-09 11:59 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[23]

嘩, 暫時拘留仲化算~~


[引用] | 作者 維珍航空 | 12-02-09 12:19 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[24] Re: 毫無人性
毫無人性 :
又一學歷高不表示道德高的實理
比如中國以前秦檜也是狀元。

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 12-02-09 4:49 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[25] Re: 維珍航空
維珍航空 :
嘩, 暫時拘留仲化算~~
唉!

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 12-02-09 4:50 AM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[26]

仲有以下

The risks NSW citizens have to go to in exposing corruption reveals, a lazy media, an inept corruption watchdog, and (up till now) an invisible opposition. So THANKS Adrian Piccoli, Barry O'Farrell , Bill Heffernan and mostly Gillian Sneddon.

Couldn't sack GS till her evidence re criminal charge interference in legal proceedings? Also Jodie Mckay Sept 2006 preselection fix to sideline Gaudry MP well before the Orkopolous presser by Iemma is quite suggestive of a knowing quarantine strategy??

I seem to recall that Nick Greiner when he was Premier, passed a whistleblower protection bill.. What happened to that law? It hasn't been repealed has it? Why doesn't someone dig it out of the archives?

> This occurs EVERYWHERE! An employee "dobs" in a fellow worker for illegal or unethical behaviour and the person punished is always the whistleblower! <
Right - look at how the nurse who reported Dr Patel's behaviour was ostracised - as well as the nurses in NSW, a few years ago - can't remember which hospital, but they were ridiculed and ostracised, and look what's happened since.
These people show a lot of guts and should be supported.

Immediately after Bob Carr’s last election win he choose a very late night sitting of Parliament to have a bill passed reducing the age of consent for males to 16. The explanation was that lowering the age of consent was “only” bringing the laws in line with other States. Would that be just a coincidence ?

You hear alot of whistleblowers down the track honestly saying 'I regret sticking my neck out, the angst and blowback has really not been worth it etc'.
But really I can't agree with that for a very practical if a little subtle reason. A whistleblower has a psychological threat to cope with - address reality and your values which scream at you to take action, or ignore reality and sublimate that pressure and knowledge.
Really it's no choice at all. The second path leads to depression, probably legal or illegal drugs, quite possibly clinical madness of living in denial. What about those coppers writing TJIF graffiti on police station walls in frustration? Apparently it stands for The Job Is F*c*ed.

Sun 16 Mar 08 (01:35pm) Good questions, Larry King. Is this a general problem or one peculiar to the “Great Australian Labor Party”?
Just before the late Bob Collins was charged with sexual abuse of Aboriginal children the Rann Government of SA appointed Collins as Administrator of aboriginal lands in the north of SA. Even though Collins was a NT politician the appointment was well received.
Channel 7’s News Director of the time wrote in the Adelaide Review: “The appointment of Collins is nothing short of inspired. It’s doubtful that a white politician with better black connections and understanding of Aboriginal culture has been born. What’s more, as a decent, direct person, he has the trust and respect of politicians of all colours...”
Pretty scary to read in hindsight, eh? I’m sure Collins was looking forward to being Administrator.
Now it looks as if the “Great Australian Labor Party” will soon push the Catholic Church off the top spot for a history of child abuse. At least the Catholics are doing a serious “clean up”. When it comes to scandals of all kinds in the Labor Party around the nation all I can see are “cover ups” not “clean ups”.

David Yeldham in 1996,took his own life in HuntersHill-very much a "Coalition man" & the same humiliationwould have awaited him..........People like Grusovin,Arena sacrificed their politicalcareers to expose the disgusting things going on-no onelistened.

Minister boy-sex claim followed furious Heffernan lobbying
By Paola Totaro State Political Editor
May 29 2003
Allegations that a senior Carr minister sexually assaulted a 15-year-old boy have emerged just days after the disgraced Liberal Senator Bill Heffernan secretly lobbied NSW colleagues to oppose the age-of-consent reforms.
The Police Integrity Commission (PIC) will investigate claims - read in the upper house late on Tuesday night by the Liberal MP Charlie Lynn - that the minister had sex with the boy and "robbed him".
Last night, the Herald confirmed that Senator Heffernan - who used the Senate to falsely accuse Justice Michael Kirby of using rent boys - came to Sydney to campaign for the defeat of the age-of-consent legislation before it was debated and passed in the lower house last week.
Mr Lynn, like Senator Heffernan, is a strong opponent of the Carr Government's reforms, which lower the male age of consent to 16, in line with girls.
Mr Lynn read from what he said was a police strike force document which allegedly contained the boy's statement, and a police officer's corroboration of it.
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/05/28/1053801447056.html
The Herald has been told that Senator Heffernan provided copies of the same material to a National Party MP. At least two Liberal MPs who are also fierce opponents of the reforms saw or had copies of the documents.
Senator Heffernan's phone calls and lobbying were described by a senior Liberal source as "furious, bordering on paranoid". A Coalition MP confirmed that the senator had been "in the corridors" in Sydney but that his phone calls were more "akin to hectoring, than lobbying".
The Premier, Bob Carr, said that while he did not believe there was the "remotest scintilla" of evidence to justify the accusations, he wanted them properly investigated.
"I insist, even though I think this has got no credibility whatsoever, that it be taken seriously. The best way is the PIC do it. One, because it has the powers of royal commission, two, because it hasinherited all the material out of the police royal commission.
"But I repeat, we've been through the Wood royal commission pedophilia reference, we have had two police commissioners, we have had two elections, we're now on the third Parliament and we only hear of these allegations when someone is trying to block passage of a modest reform that simply brings NSW into line with other states when it comes to age of consent."
The Leader of the Opposition, John Brogden - who supported the reforms - said Mr Lynn had now written to the PIC but had only told him of his plan to air the claims "shortly before he went into the chamber".
He had counselled Mr Lynn about the seriousness of the allegations and urged him to put them to the proper authorities. Mr Brogden said Mr Lynn had also told him he had obtained the documents "in recent days".
But the allegations referred to by Mr Lynn are known to have been provided many years ago by a witness, known as W26, at the Wood royal commission. W26 had received the statement from the alleged 15-year-old victim and passed it on.
In September 1997, the then Labor MLC Franca Arena claimed in Parliament that Mr Carr, the then Opposition leader Peter Collins, and the royal commissioner, Justice James Wood, had conspired to conceal the identities of highly-placed pedophiles.
The police strike force, Cori, was set up to investigate her claims in December 1997. The parliamentary privileges committee also investigated Ms Arena's conduct, including whether she had tested her allegations.
This committee included Mr Lynn, and it was provided with all the documents from Cori, including the W26 material.
It is understood the committee asked Bernard Gross, QC, whether W26 should be called to give evidence, but he advised against it.
After the inquiry, all paperwork was to have been surrendered by MPs because all evidence was heard in camera.
The Herald put several questions in writing to Senator Heffernan, but he declined to respond. He also did not return phone calls. Last night, W26 said he had not had any contact with Mr Lynn.

以上是一些我 search 來的 Reader Comments. 其中一份是講Liberal 火爆議員Bill Heffernan 曾在2003年說明一個政府言層內閣涉嫌牲侵犯男童, 仲話有一名法官Micheal Kirby 有份!

Bill Heffernan隋即被眾視為瘋子, 但3年後Miton Orokopolus 被應驗Bill Heffernan 2003年所說 是冇錯!

但恊助 NSW POLice 將Miton Orokopolus 釘死之Gillian Sneddon 即被官官相護的 NSW LABOUR PARTY 及 Parliament 妙油兼換 lock 兼吾俾她回來! 真是哀哉! 難怪 Bill Heferrnan 說 " NSW is a Disgraceful place where too may people keep too many secrets!"

PS: 難怪上面有澳洲警察爛GAG TJIF "THE JOB IS FXXXED" 我想是各項各業也是, 好人難做!


[引用] | 作者 PO BONG | 17-03-09 5:53 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[27]

更新
The risks NSW citizens have to go to in exposing corruption reveals, a lazy media, an inept corruption watchdog, and (up till now) an invisible opposition. So THANKS Adrian Piccoli, Barry O'Farrell , Bill Heffernan and mostly Gillian Sneddon.

Couldn't sack GS till her evidence re criminal charge interference in legal proceedings? Also Jodie Mckay Sept 2006 preselection fix to sideline Gaudry MP well before the Orkopolous presser by Iemma is quite suggestive of a knowing quarantine strategy??

I seem to recall that Nick Greiner when he was Premier, passed a whistleblower protection bill.. What happened to that law? It hasn't been repealed has it? Why doesn't someone dig it out of the archives?

"> This occurs EVERYWHERE! An employee "dobs" in a fellow worker for illegal or unethical behaviour and the person punished is always the whistleblower! <
Right - look at how the nurse who reported Dr Patel's behaviour was ostracised - as well as the nurses in NSW, a few years ago - can't remember which hospital, but they were ridiculed and ostracised, and look what's happened since.
These people show a lot of guts and should be supported."

"Immediately after Bob Carr’s last election win he choose a very late night sitting of Parliament to have a bill passed reducing the age of consent for males to 16. The explanation was that lowering the age of consent was “only” bringing the laws in line with other States. Would that be just a coincidence ?"

"You hear alot of whistleblowers down the track honestly saying 'I regret sticking my neck out, the angst and blowback has really not been worth it etc'.
But really I can't agree with that for a very practical if a little subtle reason. A whistleblower has a psychological threat to cope with - address reality and your values which scream at you to take action, or ignore reality and sublimate that pressure and knowledge.
Really it's no choice at all. The second path leads to depression, probably legal or illegal drugs, quite possibly clinical madness of living in denial. What about those coppers writing TJIF graffiti on police station walls in frustration? Apparently it stands for The Job Is F*c*ed."

"Sun 16 Mar 08 (01:35pm) Good questions, Larry King. Is this a general problem or one peculiar to the “Great Australian Labor Party”?
Just before the late Bob Collins was charged with sexual abuse of Aboriginal children the Rann Government of SA appointed Collins as Administrator of aboriginal lands in the north of SA. Even though Collins was a NT politician the appointment was well received.
Channel 7’s News Director of the time wrote in the Adelaide Review: “The appointment of Collins is nothing short of inspired. It’s doubtful that a white politician with better black connections and understanding of Aboriginal culture has been born. What’s more, as a decent, direct person, he has the trust and respect of politicians of all colours...”
Pretty scary to read in hindsight, eh? I’m sure Collins was looking forward to being Administrator.
Now it looks as if the “Great Australian Labor Party” will soon push the Catholic Church off the top spot for a history of child abuse. At least the Catholics are doing a serious “clean up”. When it comes to scandals of all kinds in the Labor Party around the nation all I can see are “cover ups” not “clean ups”."

"David Yeldham in 1996,took his own life in HuntersHill-very much a "Coalition man" & the same humiliationwould have awaited him..........People like Grusovin,Arena sacrificed their politicalcareers to expose the disgusting things going on-no onelistened."

Minister boy-sex claim followed furious Heffernan lobbying
By Paola Totaro State Political Editor
May 29 2003
Allegations that a senior Carr minister sexually assaulted a 15-year-old boy have emerged just days after the disgraced Liberal Senator Bill Heffernan secretly lobbied NSW colleagues to oppose the age-of-consent reforms.
The Police Integrity Commission (PIC) will investigate claims - read in the upper house late on Tuesday night by the Liberal MP Charlie Lynn - that the minister had sex with the boy and "robbed him".
Last night, the Herald confirmed that Senator Heffernan - who used the Senate to falsely accuse Justice Michael Kirby of using rent boys - came to Sydney to campaign for the defeat of the age-of-consent legislation before it was debated and passed in the lower house last week.
Mr Lynn, like Senator Heffernan, is a strong opponent of the Carr Government's reforms, which lower the male age of consent to 16, in line with girls.
Mr Lynn read from what he said was a police strike force document which allegedly contained the boy's statement, and a police officer's corroboration of it.
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/05/28/1053801447056.html
The Herald has been told that Senator Heffernan provided copies of the same material to a National Party MP. At least two Liberal MPs who are also fierce opponents of the reforms saw or had copies of the documents.
Senator Heffernan's phone calls and lobbying were described by a senior Liberal source as "furious, bordering on paranoid". A Coalition MP confirmed that the senator had been "in the corridors" in Sydney but that his phone calls were more "akin to hectoring, than lobbying".
The Premier, Bob Carr, said that while he did not believe there was the "remotest scintilla" of evidence to justify the accusations, he wanted them properly investigated.
"I insist, even though I think this has got no credibility whatsoever, that it be taken seriously. The best way is the PIC do it. One, because it has the powers of royal commission, two, because it hasinherited all the material out of the police royal commission.
"But I repeat, we've been through the Wood royal commission pedophilia reference, we have had two police commissioners, we have had two elections, we're now on the third Parliament and we only hear of these allegations when someone is trying to block passage of a modest reform that simply brings NSW into line with other states when it comes to age of consent."
The Leader of the Opposition, John Brogden - who supported the reforms - said Mr Lynn had now written to the PIC but had only told him of his plan to air the claims "shortly before he went into the chamber".
He had counselled Mr Lynn about the seriousness of the allegations and urged him to put them to the proper authorities. Mr Brogden said Mr Lynn had also told him he had obtained the documents "in recent days".
But the allegations referred to by Mr Lynn are known to have been provided many years ago by a witness, known as W26, at the Wood royal commission. W26 had received the statement from the alleged 15-year-old victim and passed it on.
In September 1997, the then Labor MLC Franca Arena claimed in Parliament that Mr Carr, the then Opposition leader Peter Collins, and the royal commissioner, Justice James Wood, had conspired to conceal the identities of highly-placed pedophiles.
The police strike force, Cori, was set up to investigate her claims in December 1997. The parliamentary privileges committee also investigated Ms Arena's conduct, including whether she had tested her allegations.
This committee included Mr Lynn, and it was provided with all the documents from Cori, including the W26 material.
It is understood the committee asked Bernard Gross, QC, whether W26 should be called to give evidence, but he advised against it.
After the inquiry, all paperwork was to have been surrendered by MPs because all evidence was heard in camera.
The Herald put several questions in writing to Senator Heffernan, but he declined to respond. He also did not return phone calls. Last night, W26 said he had not had any contact with Mr Lynn.

以上是一些我 search 來的 Reader Comments. 其中一份是講Liberal 火爆議員Bill Heffernan 曾在2003年說明一個政府言層內閣成員涉嫌牲侵犯男童, 仲話有一名法官Micheal Kirby 有份!

Bill Heffernan隋即被眾視為瘋子, 但3年後Miton Orokopolus 被捕應驗Bill Heffernan 2003年所說 是冇錯!

但恊助 NSW POLice 將Miton Orokopolus 釘死之Gillian Sneddon 即被官官相護的 NSW LABOUR PARTY 及 Parliament 妙油兼換 lock 兼吾俾她回來! 真是哀哉! 難怪 Bill Heferrnan 說 " NSW is a Disgraceful place where too may people keep too many secrets!"

PS: 難怪上面有澳洲警察爛GAG TJIF "THE JOB IS FXXXED" 我想是各項各業也是, 好人難做!

今天香港醫界大醜聞

"醫 委 會 聆 訊
接 回 家 住   醫 生 涉 迷 姦 女 病 人
評分: 7.3 (92人) 瀏覽人次: 191,200 回應: 66

【本 報 訊 】 聯 合 醫 院 前 精 神 科 醫 生 羅 文 友 , 涉 嫌 與 多 名 女 病 人 有 染 的 案 件 昨 日 完 成 審訊 , 醫 務 委 員 會 首 度 披 露 病 人 A 小 姐 的 供 詞 內 容 。 這 名 婚 姻 失 敗 及 遭 家 人 遺 棄 的 精神 病 患 者 , 在 閉 門 聆 訊 中 哭 訴 與 羅 文 友 長 達 10 年 的 醫 患 孽 緣 。 她 聲 稱 在 聯 合 醫 院與 羅 相 識 後 , 被 他 接 出 院 並 帶 返 家 中 , 其 後 更 涉 嫌 將 她 迷 姦 。 二 人 其 後 共 賦 同 居 ,展 開 遭 羅 文 友 恐 嚇 、 虐 待 及 禁 錮 的 黑 暗 歲 月 。 記 者 : 白 琳 、 張 嘉 雯
middle

貌似 50 多 歲 的 羅 文 友 昨 日 出 庭 時 精 神 萎 靡 , 頭 髮 凌 亂 , 出 入 戴 上 口 罩 及 以 公 文 袋 掩面 。 選 擇 不 答 辯 的 他 遭 律 政 司 提 出 共 15 項 專 業 失 當 指 控 , 其 中 6 項 為 與 病 人 發 生「 不 恰 當 」 接 觸 或 關 係 , 涉 及 五 名 精 神 科 病 人 , 當 中 只 有 A 小 姐 肯 出 庭 作 證 。 醫 委會 日 前 安 排 閉 門 聆 訊 , 聽 取 A 的 供 詞 。 雙 方 律 師 昨 日 結 案 陳 詞 時 , 首 度 對 外 披 露 閉門 聆 訊 內 容 。
A 小 姐 患 上 邊 緣 人 格 障 礙 及 抑 鬱 症 , 97 年 婚 姻 失 敗 自 殺 不 遂 ,入 住 聯 合 醫 院 精 神 科 , 認 識 在 該 處 任 職 的 羅 文 友 。 她 以 普 通 話 夾 雜 廣 東 話 供 稱 , 當時 遭 家 人 離 棄 , 無 依 無 靠 , 被 羅 文 友 接 出 院 , 帶 她 到 其 錦 綉 花 園 住 所 暫 住 , 「 他 說總 之 我 會 很 開 心 、 很 安 全 。 」
當 時 羅 文 友 與 同 樣 任 職 醫 生 的 妻 子 已 辦 理 分 居手 續 , 兩 人 分 房 睡 。 A 憶 述 , 羅 趁 妻 子 上 班 時 , 在 客 廳 向 她 查 問 病 情 並 借 故 親 近 ,「 不 到 半 小 時 , 他 要 親 我 這 裏 那 裏 , 我 反 抗 , 發 抖 得 很 厲 害 。 」 羅 餵 她 吃 藥 後 , 她全 身 無 力 , 被 羅 帶 到 睡 房 性 交 。 說 到 激 動 處 , A 在 庭 上 失 聲 痛 哭 , 「 我 走 投 無 路 ,點 同 佢 老 婆 講 , 我 俾 佢 強 姦 呢 ? 」

禁 錮 數 月 「 要 我 跪 下 叩 頭 」

zoom

戴 上 口 罩 的 羅 文 友 昨 日 出 庭 時 頭 髮 凌 亂 , 精 神 萎 靡 。 凌 樹 輝 攝

A 當 時 在 羅 家 住 了 約 兩 周 , 就 被 安 置 到 另 一 住 所 , 與 羅 共 賦 同 居 。 此 後 10 年 羅 一 直是 A 的 經 濟 支 柱 , 曾 分 手 及 復 合 , 06 年 A 偷 偷 向 聯 合 醫 院 告 發 羅 未 經 授 權 下 查 看其 病 歷 及 與 她 發 生 親 密 關 係 。
控 方 指 出 , 精 神 科 專 科 醫 生 、 現 任 立 法 會 議 員潘 珮 璆 當 時 致 電 羅 , 告 知 聯 合 醫 院 接 獲 有 關 投 訴 。 A 供 稱 , 羅 一 怒 之 下 禁 錮 她 , 迫她 撰 寫 向 聯 合 醫 院 求 情 等 多 封 信 件 , 「 他 關 了 我 幾 個 月 , 不 讓 我 吃 , 不 讓 我 睡 。 要我 跪 下 、 叩 頭 , 叩 到 我 的 頭 都 腫 了 、 膝 蓋 也 腫 。 他 跟 他 弟 弟 一 起 監 視 我 。 」
A 又 聲 稱 不 斷 遭 羅 恐 嚇 , 若 她 再 告 密 , 羅 將 「 搵 殺 手 殺 我 」 , 並 對 傳 媒 揭 露 其 病 歷 ,以 及 吩 咐 「 其 他 有 性 關 係 的 女 性 朋 友 」 電 話 騷 擾 她 。 羅 曾 要 求 她 使 用 其 提 款 卡 到 銀行 提 款 , 以 便 閉 路 電 視 拍 到 她 獨 自 外 出 , 製 造 羅 沒 有 禁 錮 她 的 假 象 。

相 擁 自 拍 照 作 呈 堂 證 物

A 的 呈 堂 證 物 包 括 兩 人 的 相 擁 自 拍 照 , 相 中 的 羅 赤 膊 , 背 景 似 有 一 張 睡 床 ; 另 有 羅 帶她 出 席 緬 甸 校 友 聯 合 會 及 二 人 與 羅 的 兒 子 的 合 照 。 其 他 證 物 包 括 多 張 銀 行 及 信 用 卡單 據 , 證 實 羅 曾 於 07 至 08 年 花 近 10 萬 元 在 A 身 上 , 包 括 勞 力 士 名 錶 及 首 飾 。 A 聲 稱 羅 欲 藉 此 避 免 她 再 向 醫 院 投 訴 。
辯 方 律 師 昨 日 多 番 質 疑 A , 指 其 供 詞 內容 不 合 常 理 。 紀 錄 顯 示 羅 06 年 3 月 曾 報 案 稱 住 所 遭 人 爆 竊 , 若 羅 確 實 正 在 禁 錮 A , 根 本 不 會 報 警 ; A 偷 錄 的 兩 人 對 話 沒 有 上 述 內 容 , 只 有 羅 「 教 」 A 撰 寫 信 件 及 帶 A 學 跳 舞 等 零 碎 對 話 。

另 涉 四 病 人 不 恰 當 接 觸

除了 A 小 姐 , 05 至 06 年 間 , 羅 被 指 與 另 外 四 名 病 人 發 生 「 不 恰 當 」 接 觸 或 關 係 , 包括 與 F 小 姐 學 社 交 舞 ; 分 別 與 D 及 E 小 姐 共 晉 午 餐 , E 更 主 動 建 議 羅 租 住 其 物 業 ;又 試 圖 為 C 小 姐 繳 付 駕 駛 考 試 費 。 羅 另 涉 嫌 不 適 當 管 有 精 神 科 病 人 資 料 及 以 個 人 手帳 記 下 部 份 病 人 的 手 提 電 話 號 碼 。
15 項 指 控 中 , 羅 只 承 認 8 項 , 包 括 未 經 授權 下 攫 取 A 小 姐 及 B 先 生 的 電 子 病 歷 、 沒 有 把 病 人 吃 剩 的 精 神 科 藥 物 歸 還 醫 院 藥 房等 。 控 辯 雙 方 昨 完 成 結 案 陳 詞 , 醫 委 會 將 於 5 月 1 日 裁 決 。"


[引用] | 作者 PO BONG | 17-03-09 6:00 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]

[28]

唉,咁多醜聞......

Chris
[引用] | 作者 Chris | 17-03-09 9:03 PM | [舉報垃圾留言]